‘A botanical paradise with spectacular views’: The hotel you need to visit on your next trip to Cork
‘A botanical paradise with spectacular views’: The hotel you need to visit on your next...

Shayna Sappington

‘I’m an obstetrician who became pregnant with twins via an egg donor. This month they turn 5’
‘I’m an obstetrician who became pregnant with twins via an egg donor. This month they...

Amanda Cassidy

Period dramas on Netflix and Amazon Prime to watch while we wait for ‘The Crown’
Period dramas on Netflix and Amazon Prime to watch while we wait for ‘The Crown’

Erin Lindsay

The world’s most sustainable travel spots revealed
The world’s most sustainable travel spots revealed

Amanda Cassidy

Indoor Halloween activities for kids to get you through the mid-term
Indoor Halloween activities for kids to get you through the mid-term

Lauren Heskin

Planning a festive trip to London this year? These hotels really know how to do Christmas
Planning a festive trip to London this year? These hotels really know how to do...

Sarah Finnan

16 great prints and posters to add some life to your walls
16 great prints and posters to add some life to your walls

Megan Burns

‘Mummy has cancer’: How to talk to children about a parent’s diagnosis
‘Mummy has cancer’: How to talk to children about a parent’s diagnosis

Amanda Cassidy

15 dogs who are costume-ready for Halloween
15 dogs who are costume-ready for Halloween

Grace McGettigan

Bringing unsexy back: putting the freaky back into Halloween
Bringing unsexy back: putting the freaky back into Halloween

Jessie Collins

Image / Agenda / Breaking Stories

CervicalCheck Tribunal: Vicky Phelan says patients’ concerns have been completely ignored


by Megan Burns
22nd Oct 2020

Vicky Phelan via Twitter

Vicky Phelan

Minister for Health Stephen Donnelly announced October 27 as the start date for the CervicalCheck Tribunal, but campaigner Vicky Phelan says the concerns of women and families affected have been ignored.


With the announcement by Minister for Health Stephen Donnelly that the CervicalCheck Tribunal would commence work on October 27, campaigner Vicky Phelan expressed her anger at “a flat rejection of all of our concerns”.

The tribunal, which was supposed to begin in March, had been delayed by the Covid-19 pandemic, and is intended to act as an alternative to legal proceedings for those affected by misread cervical cancer screenings. There are 203 active claims related to the the CervicalCheck scandal, while a further eight have been resolved.

On Twitter, Vicky Phelan raised a number of ways in which the announcement ignores the issues raised by CervicalCheck patient support group, 221+.

Firstly, she was shocked at the minister’s announcement came on the same day that the group received a letter informing them of the tribunal’s start date, giving them no prior warning that the start date was so imminent, not to mention that this date falls just as the country is going back into its highest level of lockdown.

“The @221plus women & families who this Tribunal is aimed at, were not afforded an opportunity to respond to the Minister’s decision to formally establish the Tribunal BEFORE it was announced.” Vicky tweeted. “As we have become used to, those most affected are often the last to know.”

She goes on to explain that the group met the minister six weeks ago over video call and outlined several concerns about the tribunal, all of which, she says, have been rejected by this announcement.

Firstly, she says, they asked for a non-adversarial route to be found for the Tribunal, one not requiring women to fight the labs which misread their tests.

“Women could instead rely on the non-delegable duty owed to them by the HSE, who were found primarily responsible for the cervical screening programme in the Morrissey case. The HSE could then rely on their contractual and legal indemnities against the lab,” Vicky says.

“The Minister rejected these arguments and set out in his letter how the laboratories MUST be involved in proceedings if taken before the Tribunal. This will NOT be acceptable to many of our members.”

Secondly, she explains that they asked that applicants to the Tribunal who receive an award be allowed to return to the Tribunal should they suffer a recurrence of their cancer. She gives the example of how the State allowed applicants in the Hepatitis C Tribunal to return if their health deteriorated.

This right, she points out, would be preferable to the High Court rules, which do not allow a return, however she says the minister did not address this concern at all.

Thirdly, Vicky points out that the group is concerned that the Statute of Limitations may prevent some of their members getting justice.

“We explained to the Minister that some of our members have received legal advice that they may now be statute-barred because they relied on the Government’s promise of a ‘non-adversarial’ Tribunal and did not issue HC proceedings.”

“These members may now, through no fault of their own, be statute-barred because of delays by Government of more than two years in establishing this Tribunal. The Minister did not address this issue.”

She concludes by saying that the Tribunal therefore does not prioritise the needs of the women affected, and asks the minister to reconsider. If it does go ahead in the current format, she says, they will be recommending that members of 221+ do not participate.

Featured image: Vicky Phelan


Read more: Cancer and Covid-19: “I finished radiotherapy in January. I haven’t seen a doctor since February”

Read more: Video: Vicky Phelan does experiment with her son to highlight the importance of hand-washing

Read more: Meath woman who lived through Spanish flu offers message of hope on her 107th birthday

 

 

Also Read

pregnancy speculation
IMAGE WRITES
Seriously, it’s time to stop with the celebrity pregnancy speculation

The endless speculation about who’s pregnant or trying to conceive is exhausting, and frankly I don’t think any of us...

By Sarah Finnan

Prince Harry and Meghan Markle
BREAKING STORIES
Prince Harry and Meghan Markle make Time 100 Most Influential People list

Prince Harry and Meghan Markle have appeared on their first cover together, having been named by Time magazine among the...

By Holly O'Neill

Sinead Brady
premium BUSINESS
CAREERS IN CONVERSATION: Seminar 2 Your Next Steps

The second instalment of Sinead Brady’s career seminar series focuses on what constitutes success and how to decide what’s next...

By IMAGE

blank
BREAKING STORIES, CULTURE
We’re all here for Bill Murray’s golfing tour around Ireland

The legendary Groundhog Day actor is visiting Ireland this week to film a new season of golf series The Links...

By Jennifer McShane

frostbit
BREAKING STORIES
‘You wouldn’t be long getting frostbit’ is now Ireland’s Forrest Gump

You wouldn’t be long getting hypothermia. Ruairí McSorley, aka the viral Frostbit Boy, has braved the elements again, and once...

By Holly O'Neill

Emily Ratajkowski Blurred Lines
BREAKING STORIES
It’s awful, but not surprising that Emily Ratajkowski says she was sexually assaulted on the set of Blurred Lines

In her new book, the model accuses Robin Thicke of groping her on the set of the controversial music video in 2013.

By Megan Burns

Brad Pitt
IMAGE WRITES
Brad Pitt’s decision to work with Harvey Weinstein speaks volumes

Still embroiled in a very nasty custody battle, Angelina Jolie’s recent comments about Brad Pitt do little to redeem him...

By Sarah Finnan