30 life questions that will strengthen your closest friendships
30 life questions that will strengthen your closest friendships

Geraldine Carton

7 comforting films worth watching to take your mind off Covid
7 comforting films worth watching to take your mind off Covid

Jennifer McShane

This Dalkey home, with sea access and incredible views, is on sale for €3.95 million
This Dalkey home, with sea access and incredible views, is on sale for €3.95 million

Megan Burns

Pandemic regrets: 20 things we would have done differently if we’d known what was ahead
Pandemic regrets: 20 things we would have done differently if we’d known what was ahead

Amanda Cassidy

Marianne Smyth, aka @smythsisters, picks 42 summer staples
Marianne Smyth, aka @smythsisters, picks 42 summer staples

Holly O'Neill

Paris Hilton and the physical, verbal and emotional abuse she suffered while at boarding school
Paris Hilton and the physical, verbal and emotional abuse she suffered while at boarding school

Lauren Heskin

Afore After: The new womenswear brand that’s so sustainable, it uses buttons made from Irish milk
Afore After: The new womenswear brand that’s so sustainable, it uses buttons made from Irish...

Sarah Finnan

6 new Netflix picks we can’t wait to watch in August
6 new Netflix picks we can’t wait to watch in August

Jennifer McShane

Friendship fallout in a pandemic: “I realised that nobody had picked up the phone to see how was I doing”
Friendship fallout in a pandemic: “I realised that nobody had picked up the phone to...

Niamh Ennis

Sophie Toscan du Plantier: 10 questions we’re still asking about the case
Sophie Toscan du Plantier: 10 questions we’re still asking about the case

Jennifer McShane

Image / Self

Please stop asking me when I’m going to have a baby!


by Amanda Cassidy
13th Oct 2020

“Have you any good news for us yet?” It is one of the most insensitive and irritating questions you may ever be unlucky enough to hear, but for many couples, this is a regular occurrence.


Wanting to start a family and not being successful is a private and painful matter. Being questioned about the finer details not only puts additional pressure on those experiencing fertility issues but it can often be upsetting.

After three years of marriage, Adele Barbao was still struggling to get pregnant so she decided to seek help. “IVF sucks. It is the most time consuming, invasive, expensive and emotionally painful roller coaster I have been on. It actually broke me. You have so much invested in the process, financially and emotionally that it consumes your every thought. When you are having difficulty conceiving, it seems everyone around you is falling pregnant. It’s easy to be happy for them at first but that brave face wears thin after a while. I even started to decline going to certain get-togethers and attending baby birthdays were just painful. I became quite bitter, desperate and depressed.”

Adele, originally from Melbourne says she was asked when she was going to have a baby repeatedly while going through IVF. “I’d answer with a forced smile ‘we are just enjoying being newly married’, we have some travelling we want to do first,’ or ‘I’m just focusing on my career right now’. I wasn’t always that pleasant. One day I responded with ‘it’s not that easy, you know.’ I had just gotten my period that morning… again. People would tell me that I’m not going to be young forever or that my maternal clock was ticking. And believe me, I knew it. I just didn’t need to hear it from everyone else.”

Dr John Kennedy is the medical director of the Sims Fertility clinic in Dublin. He says the emotional toll of trying for a baby can be just as difficult as the physical side of treatment. “In truth – there are few things that are more devastating than an unsuccessful cycle of IVF. It can be desperately disappointing which is why we try to manage expectations. But we are dealing with a potential life, a potential new member of this person’s family. The rewards are so exceptional that it is bound to come with disappointments.” Adele is now a proud mum to baby Harvey but says she still can’t avoid the awkward questions. “We were one of the lucky ones. But many couples will be trying for years. And some may never succeed and my heart goes out to them.

Even though we went through IVF and had such a struggle to have our Harvey, soon after we were asked… ‘so when are you having number two?’ And now that I have two wonderful children and I feel our family is pretty complete, the question still comes.”

Sive is 36 and has just finished her sixth round of IVF. She says it has come to the stage where she has started distancing herself from friends to avoid the questions that inevitably come. “I know I’m hypersensitive to anything connected to babies and kids, but I find it too difficult to attend events where I know people are going to be asking me about my own baby plans. I don’t think people even realise how upsetting it is to have to be put on the spot like that. I’m always surprised that people aren’t more sensitive to what may be going on behind closed doors. I mean, what do they expect me to say?”

Sive is currently weighing up whether or not she and her partner will go for another cycle of IVF, but she says the experience has taken its toll. “The question for us now is if we will go for a donor egg or look into adopting. Either way, we have a long road ahead, but our desire to have a baby is still as strong as ever – I just wish I didn’t have to face other people’s questions when I’m not even sure which way is up at the moment.”

Psychologists have compared the emotions of failing to conceive similar to those associated with grief. Typical reactions include shock, grief, depression, anger, frustration as well as a loss of control and loss of self-confidence. Fertility medication can have tricky side effects and relationships may suffer. Anyone going through that endless cycle of hope and disappointment will tell you that well-meaning but misguided opinions and advice add to the challenges of trying to get pregnant.

And then there are those who have decided not to have children. 34-year-old broadcaster Joanne McNally has spoken out about the reactions she gets after she answers the baby question honestly. “You are dismissed as cold-hearted, hedonistic, immature. You’ll be warned that you’ll change your mind. You will eventually succumb” they tell you, ‘you will have a baby someday’.” It is very invasive.”

A friend of mine recently became a mother after a long journey with fertility treatment. I asked her for her take on it. “I was horrified that I was getting these questions about my sexual health and well-being. I always felt very unprepared. It was like they were sticking their hand into an open wound”.

“I wonder what they would have thought if I asked them a particularly intimate question about their private lives, like how many times they masturbate or how much money they make, for example.”

Many parents will know that it doesn’t even stop when you actually have a baby. Immediately the ‘when are you giving them a brother or sister?’ questions start, which can be equally infuriating. So no matter how burning your desire is to know when somebody else is going to reproduce (or if they are going to), think twice – you never know what’s really going on (and it is really none of your business either).

Also Read

change
ADVICE
Stuck in a life rut and ready for a change? Here’s how to make it happen

You’re stuck. You’re totally fed up watching, as everyone seems to glide past you, moving on up to newer brighter...

By Niamh Ennis

PARENTHOOD
What actually consitutes self-care when you’re a mother

Self-care is all very well in theory but what about when there are tiny humans, quite literally, crawling on your...

By Sophie White

RELATIONSHIPS
Can you ever really be friends with an ex?

“Can we still be friends?” It’s a question I’ve been asked a couple of times and for various reasons, I’ve...

By Grace McGettigan

PARENTHOOD
Olympian swimmer “disappointed” she had to leave breastfeeding son at home

Spanish synchronised swimmer Ona Carbonell has said she is disappointed and disillusioned that she cannot take her breastfeeding son with...

By Jennifer McShane

ADVICE
What can ancient philosophers teach us about love today?

What do the philosophers say about love? Quite a bit. Philosophy lecturer Alissa MacMillan says we can learn a lot...

By IMAGE

premium IMAGE WRITES, HEALTH & WELLNESS
Lynn Enright: ‘It’s no wonder young women are vaccine hesitant’

We shouldn’t rush to ridicule or admonish vaccine hesitant young women. Their fears and concerns need to be addressed with clear and appropriate messaging

By Lynn Enright

REAL-LIFE STORIES
Inside the secret world of Ireland’s kink, BDSM and swinging scene

The secretive world of swinging and kink might just be the most healthy approach to casual sex in Ireland today discovers Sophie White as she dives into the world of rigging, Daddy-Doms and impact play.

By Sophie White