Shop Irish this Christmas: Meet Bronwyn Thomson from Sandymount’s favourite gift shop
Shop Irish this Christmas: Meet Bronwyn Thomson from Sandymount’s favourite gift shop

Lauren Heskin

A gynaecologist asked women to redesign his office and the responses are amazing
A gynaecologist asked women to redesign his office and the responses are amazing

Sarah Finnan

Your party season beauty kit, from red lipstick to shiny hair
Your party season beauty kit, from red lipstick to shiny hair

Holly O'Neill

Michael Sheen is now a ‘not-for-profit actor’ after selling 2 of his houses for charity
Michael Sheen is now a ‘not-for-profit actor’ after selling 2 of his houses for charity

Sarah Finnan

‘I was a child who received a Christmas shoebox. This is what it meant to me’
‘I was a child who received a Christmas shoebox. This is what it meant to...

Amanda Cassidy

Keep your pearly whites shining bright this party season
Keep your pearly whites shining bright this party season

Sarah Finnan

Shop Irish this Christmas: Meet Margaret O’Rourke, jeweller and owner of MoMuse
Shop Irish this Christmas: Meet Margaret O’Rourke, jeweller and owner of MoMuse

Lauren Heskin

How to approach the Santa reveal for suspicious minds (without losing the Christmas magic)
How to approach the Santa reveal for suspicious minds (without losing the Christmas magic)

Amanda Cassidy

Chris Noth weighs in on Kim Cattrall’s falling out with SJP
Chris Noth weighs in on Kim Cattrall’s falling out with SJP

Sarah Finnan

Some important tips from Met Eireann as the eye of Storm Barra hits
Some important tips from Met Eireann as the eye of Storm Barra hits

Sarah Finnan

Image / Editorial

The Problem With Kate Middleton’s “Princess” Comment


By Jennifer McShane
25th Jan 2017

LONDON, ENGLAND - MAY 04: Catherine, Duchess of Cambridge visits the "Vogue 100: A Century Of Style" exhibition at National Portrait Gallery on May 4, 2016 in London, England. The Duchess appears on the cover of the centenary issue in June 2016. (Photo by Ian Gavan - WPA Pool/Getty Images)

The Problem With Kate Middleton’s “Princess” Comment

I hold my hand up and say that I was a wannabe princess-in-waiting as a young child. Disney princesses, Princess Diana; they were a fixture in books and on TV, and yes, I would idly dream of the day I got to wear the ball gown, being The Fairest One of All. But the world was a different place, it was a different time, and I thought no further than glass slippers. ?I can’t remember what age I was when I thought that being confined to a tower waiting for a prince all sounded very dull and boring, while the boys got to have the adventures.

From toys?to clothes, children are told how they should act?from the beginning. Girls are ladylike; they wear pink dresses, they’re precious and pretty, while boys are the opposite; rough and ready to score goals and save the world. Those ideas still exist in 2017. Even birthday cards still grasp at this concept, for God’s sake. ?The only princess that disbanded this ideal, for me, was Princess Leia, played by the late, brilliant Carrie Fisher. She flipped the switch on what it meant to be considered a mere princess – she was smart, savvy, quick-witted and took no prisoners; she was a hero in her own right. And we’ve moved towards that, Disney has given us a slew of independent, ballsy female characters that challenge the status quo from the powerful Elsa from Frozen to the tough-as-nails, bow-slinging Princess Merida from Brave – these are kick-ass women, giving new meaning to what it is to be a modern princess.

Which is why, when I read that Kate Middleton, the Duchess of Cambridge, was overheard?telling a four-year-old named Daisy that she was “very lucky” to be a princess because she was “well looked after by her husband”, my heart sank. Now, if your daughter loves the traditional sense of being a princess, that’s fine. There’s absolutely nothing wrong with this. But there’s another side to the issue as it’s a complex one; to some women, the idea of being a princess is an honour; a big deal, given only to the?brave, very best of women. Others see it as a damaging stereotype ??another box for women try to fit into, who will fail miserably if they don’t have beautiful long hair, an impossibly small waist or their very own prince to save the day (eh, save your own day!). The Duchess of Cambridge’s comments were (likely unknowingly) presented as the only view a four-year-old girl could potentially have?of herself as a princess. And that’s a potential problem.

It’s also a completely regressive statement to make at a time when women are shouting for change – when not four days ago?millions of women around the world went out to fight and challenge sexism, bigotry, misogyny and extremism. What sort of message is that sending to Daisy, Daisy’s friends and the many impressionable young women who could hear those comments? On the other hand, yes, it’s a mere comment, it could have been said in jest, but it’s disheartening all the same – even at four, young children are hugely perceptive – and it feels like we’re taking us a step back when we are trying to leap forwards. For a woman who is so warm, engaging and intelligent, it’s disappointing. Kate meant the comments kindly, but it isn’t the point. She is a woman of considerable influence?in the public eye, looked upon by millions, and there is a responsibility that comes with that – and why give her husband all the credit for the role she has dedicated her life to? She does many commendable things in her own right, why not mention this also?

When so many of us are fighting to be heard, Kate has a platform from which she can campaign on behalf of women, rather than pigeonholing her position, and by association, her gender.