This Sandycove home on the market for €1.95 million is stunning inside and out
This Sandycove home on the market for €1.95 million is stunning inside and out

Megan Burns

Meet the Irish designer brightening people’s homes with her beautiful designs
Meet the Irish designer brightening people’s homes with her beautiful designs

Sarah Finnan

Can we stop pretending that Jamie Spears did Britney a favour by petitioning to end the conservatorship
Can we stop pretending that Jamie Spears did Britney a favour by petitioning to end...

Lauren Heskin

‘A story of being trafficked’: Prince Andrew’s accuser Virginia Giuffre has a right to be heard
‘A story of being trafficked’: Prince Andrew’s accuser Virginia Giuffre has a right to be...

Jennifer McShane

‘Creative minds always thrive in adversity’: Author Louise Candlish on her latest (greatest) thriller
‘Creative minds always thrive in adversity’: Author Louise Candlish on her latest (greatest) thriller

Amanda Cassidy

Rotunda Hospital to extend visiting hours for partners of pregnant women
Rotunda Hospital to extend visiting hours for partners of pregnant women

Jennifer McShane

15 underrated Netflix gems that will distract you from the news
15 underrated Netflix gems that will distract you from the news

Jennifer McShane

‘Sleeptember’ and how to create an adult bedtime routine that actually works
‘Sleeptember’ and how to create an adult bedtime routine that actually works

Sarah Finnan

Actor Richard E Grant reveals late wife Joan had lung cancer
Actor Richard E Grant reveals late wife Joan had lung cancer

Jennifer McShane

Kitchen accessories under €30 to get you excited to cook again
Kitchen accessories under €30 to get you excited to cook again

Megan Burns

Image / Editorial

Opinion: Here’s what’s wrong with JK Rowling’s comments on trans people


by Lauren Heskin
08th Jun 2020
blank

Gender is not as binary as JK Rowling’s recent tweets would have you believe. Here’s why, aside from its social constructs, gender isn’t certain.


This week, author JK Rowling tweeted this:

This is not her first foray into anti-transgender discourse and a reductive understanding of biological sex. Back in December 2019, Rowling was then tweeting her support for Maya Forstater, a woman who was fired from her job for tweeting her opposition to a British proposal that would allow people to identify as the opposite sex.

As we see the same anti-transgender attitude crop up once again (in another tweet, she suggested she would march with the trans community “if” they were ever discriminated against on the basis of being trans), we’ve decided to revisit this explainer on gender and biological sex.

Last year, Forstater’s appeal to the UK employment tribunal was dismissed and Rowling tweeted, “Dress however you please. Call yourself whatever you like. Sleep with any consenting adult who’ll have you. Live your best life in peace and security. But force women out of their jobs for stating that sex is real? #IStandWithMaya #ThisIsNotADrill”


Stripping away all of the social constructs that so tightly define men and women, Rowling here is arguing that biological gender is a scientific and indisputable fact. And on the surface, it seems like a legitimate statement – most of us are born with a male or female external organ after all.

But the truth is much more complicated than that.

Because you see, scientifically speaking, gender is not binary. Scientists use a three-factor method to identify sex and they’re known as the three G’s – genes, gonads and genitals. Genes refer to whether you have two X chromosomes (female) or an X and a Y chromosome (male). Gonads refer to your internal sexual organs – testes or ovaries. And finally genitals, or your external sexual organs.

You probably have a rough understanding of these from biology class, but did you know that only when all of these markers are fulfilled can sex be scientifically confirmed? Between 2-5% of the population do not hit all three of these markers. That’s a handful of people in every 100 that do not fulfil the scientific definition of their sex.

And in fact,  some scientists argue that there are more than two sexes – professor of Biology and Gender Studies at Brown University Anne Fausto-Sterling has argued that there are in fact five. This is because the three Gs definition is somewhat simplistic and can be broken down further. Males and females who have the corresponding gonads and genitals can have an extra X or Y chromosome. Females can have an extra X chromosome (XXX) and approximately 1 in 600 people with male gonads and genitals have an extra X chromosome (XXY) and 1 in 1,000 have an extra Y.

Sexual expression relies on a complex process of gene mutation and any slight differentiation can affect hormone production, physiological function or physical traits. Female genes may express female organs but also create typically “male” elements like high levels of testosterone while still being able to complete all of the “female” tasks like becoming pregnant.

The reality is that biological sex is a spectrum. Even if you satisfy the genes-gonads-genitals rule in general, there may be discrepancies within each one. Just like a colour may appear red but on closer inspection has pockets of pink and orange. Even the 2-5% who don’t perfectly fit the scientific definition of genes-gonads-genital sex could be higher because, depending on the level of those discrepancies, people might go their entire lives without knowing that their gender isn’t a perfect fit.

Sex isn’t binary, it’s not a scientific certainty and it should not be confused with gender, which is a social construct. The sooner we start understanding that, the more compassionate, nurturing world we will be.


Read more: This is why JK Rowling is facing a backlash on Twitter

Read more: The Caster Semenya ruling and why the IAAF are on the wrong side of history

Read more: My trans child: ‘Everyone’s journey is different, but seeing your child happy is every parent’s ultimate goal’

Also Read

blank
premium EDITORIAL
EVENT: How To Master the Art of Negotiation

We sit down with Negotiation Strategist Natalie Reynolds, discussing key tactics and strategies used to master the art of negotiation...

By Shayna Sappington

blank
IMAGE WRITES
The sexist commentary at Wimbledon still remains a problem

Wimbledon in 2021 and once again female athletes are singled out on the playing field, a great deal of the...

By Jennifer McShane

blank
EDITORIAL
This spatchcock chicken recipe will make your weekend

This is a great way to get a juicy roast chicken, bursting with flavour.     Bord Bia’s Spatchcock Chicken...

By Meg Walker

Mandy Moore pumping
EDITORIAL
Mandy Moore climbed an active volcano at dawn… while pumping

Hiking a mountain and breast pumping – now, that’s what we call multitasking at its finest. Mandy Moore enjoyed an...

By Sarah Finnan

blank
EDITORIAL
‘Why do we keep snatching normality away from our children?’

This summer the government will allow my children into a bar, but not to their gymnastics camp. Amanda Cassidy on...

By Amanda Cassidy

blank
EDITORIAL
Attending multiple weddings this year? How to save money as a guest

These days, going to a wedding is the equivalent of going on a short holiday in terms of cost. From...

By Jennifer McShane

Full House, onscreen father Danny Tanner
EDITORIAL
We’re remembering our favourite onscreen dads for Father’s Day

With Father’s Day just around the corner (this Sunday 20h June, so yes, you do have time to buy yours...

By Grace McGettigan