Why best friends Simone Biles and Jordan Chiles are the joy of the Olympics
Why best friends Simone Biles and Jordan Chiles are the joy of the Olympics

Jennifer McShane

Ashton Kutcher and Mila Kunis like to not wash regularly
Ashton Kutcher and Mila Kunis like to not wash regularly

Holly O'Neill

Zoë Kravitz: When did women’s nipples become such a societal taboo?
Zoë Kravitz: When did women’s nipples become such a societal taboo?

Sarah Finnan

‘Bathed in love’: The inspirational success story of one of Ireland’s Chernobyl children
‘Bathed in love’: The inspirational success story of one of Ireland’s Chernobyl children

Tania Reut

5 cult beauty staples you need for a post-lockdown upgrade
5 cult beauty staples you need for a post-lockdown upgrade

IMAGE

This €12 product helped me get rid of ALL my body acne in my thirties (really)
This €12 product helped me get rid of ALL my body acne in my thirties...

Jennifer McShane

Post-lockdown dating diaries: ‘I’m more seasoned in casual sex than dating’
Post-lockdown dating diaries: ‘I’m more seasoned in casual sex than dating’

Hannah Kingston

US Paralympians to be paid the same as Olympians for the first time ever
US Paralympians to be paid the same as Olympians for the first time ever

Sarah Finnan

‘Stop treating my child’s Down Syndrome as a tragedy’ – One mother’s story
‘Stop treating my child’s Down Syndrome as a tragedy’ – One mother’s story

Amanda Cassidy

What to eat this week: Kerala vegan cauliflower curry
What to eat this week: Kerala vegan cauliflower curry

Meg Walker

Image / Editorial

Can Do Sex And Can Do Serious


by Bill O'Sullivan
17th Jun 2014
blank

Cosmo Editor Joanna Coles spoke to the Guardian about their first National Magazine Award, SATC, and Girls

Today a Guardian interview with Cosmopolitan’s Editor-in-Chief Joanna Coles for the Cannes Lions Festival, re-surfaced the longstanding debate around women’s magazines and their reputation in the public domain. Speaking of the positive impact of Sex and the City on women’s sexuality in the 1990s, and its evolution into Girls, Coles was called upon to answer the question of whether Cosmopolitan should now be taken seriously since its award last month. In May, Cosmo won a prestigious National Magazine Award for a 12-page piece entitled ‘Your Guide To Contraception’. It was a well-deserved moment of vindication for the magazine, which won its first ever NM Award after 50 years in the business (as the publication we know it as today, thanks to Helen Gurley Brown’s 1962 takeover). But it was also a great triumph for women’s magazines at large. Cosmo beat GQ and Money to the prize in the ?personal services? category, thereby defeating two opponents who would normally have been considered favourites for it.

It’s a significant victory for Cosmo, no less because it rehashed a controversy generated a year ago from a Port Magazine cover story entitled ?A New Golden Age?. The Golden Age it referred to was that of print media, which was illustrated with a photographic portrait of seven editors – all male, all Caucasian. Vogue‘s Anna Wintour had been asked to take part, and reportedly declined, but nonetheless the debate the cover sparked did much to reveal how women’s magazines have been neglected by the awarding bodies and by the public’s perception. A New Republic article entitled ?Can Women’s Magazines Do Serious Journalism???looked into how women’s magazines had not been nominated in more than 30 years for ‘reporting? (one of eight NMA categories), nor had any women’s magazines been nominated in over a decade for ?profile writing?, and not once in 20 years for ?fiction?. What’s more, women’s magazines have a category unto themselves – ‘service and fashion magazines?, whilst men’s magazines are consigned to ?general interest?. The facts support New Republic?s then conclusion – ?The message from the arbiters is clear: women’s magazines just aren’t up to snuff.?

The criteria for the awards is generally acknowledged to pivot around two details – length and ‘serious journalism?. In both these areas, women’s magazines supposedly fall down. And yet, when studied closely, Harper’s Bazaar‘s longest piece last year ran at 4,000 words, with a Marie Claire piece on ovarian cancer running at 5,000 words, according to New Republic. Further scrutiny would also suggest that, similarly to women’s magazines, upon opening something like Esquire or GQ, many of the articles feature lengthy pieces about shoes and ‘dress to impress? style pieces. The difference is in the way these pieces are perceived by both the industry and the reader. The New York Post reported on the awards ceremony by describing Cosmo’s victory as “the greatest surprise” and concluded that the night “was not all upsets”.

The award picked up by Cosmopolitan last month can be seen as a response to the outrage that broke out last year. Women’s magazines have a far larger readership than men’s or ?general interest? magazines, and that is without including online magazines and blogs, in which blogs geared towards women outnumber those geared towards men once again. While magazine publishing has undergone a sea-change in recent years, it is good to see that the awarding body, the industry and the readership itself have all sharpened their focus on the value (and potential value) of women’s publications. All three need to strive to change the pervasively negative perception of the industry. One would hope that these magazines could cover both serious issues (such as the contraception issue covered by Cosmo) and lighter women’s issues and sex-related topics that sell copies (see above, this month’s ?Your Ultimate Guide To Oral – For Both Of You?) and still be considered reputable and serious publications. The onus is on the industry and the readership both to make a shift occur – we’ve been given enough bad press.

A brilliant list of longform and ‘serious? pieces from women’s magazines was collated by The Atlantic. Also note the list of women who have written for women’s magazines – from Virginia Woolf to Norah Ephron.

Roisin Agnew @Roxeenna

Also Read

blank
EDITORIAL
Book gift ideas for every kind of reader

Anyone who said books and socks make for boring gifts has clearly never received a delightfully absorbing book or a...

By Amanda Kavanagh

Britta Baranowsky The Flowerfield
EDITORIAL
Happy World Bee Day: These are the best bee-friendly flowers to plant right now

Attracting bees to your outdoor patch is a cinch, with a little forward-planning. We speak to two flower growers in...

By Amanda Kavanagh

audiobooks
EDITORIAL
6 brilliant audiobooks worth listening to during lockdown

Six great audiobooks to listen to in lockdown. It took me ages to come around to the idea of audiobooks....

By Jennifer McShane

blank
AGENDA, EDITORIAL
TV presenter Kate Garraway says husband Derek is still “devastated by Covid”

Kate Garraway’s devastating Covid story is a reminder of why we must keep each other in mind as an invisible...

By Jennifer McShane

blank
EDITORIAL
Setting mental health boundaries: ‘I didn’t expect the level of anger it caused’

The entitled backlash when someone tries to set their own boundaries is concerning, writes Amanda Cassidy “One particular friend just...

By Amanda Cassidy

blank
EDITORIAL
‘Quite interesting’: Princess Anne comments on The Crown

We’ve all heard that the royal family don’t exactly gather round to watch The Crown, but one member has shared...

By Jennifer McShane

house for sale in Rathmines
EDITORIAL
This beautifully finished end of terrace on Rathmines Road is on the market for just over the million mark

Built around 1860, the Victorian house for sale in Rathmines has all of the period features you would expect with...

By Lauren Heskin