‘The McGinley murders are utterly tragic, but we must not forget compassion’
20th May 2021
The devastating trial of Deirdre Morley – charged with the murder of her three children – has reached a verdict, but news coverage makes for deeply distressing reading. Jennifer McShane wonders if it's necessary and whether it lacks compassion and empathy.
Deirdre Morley was so severely mentally ill that she thought her own life and that of her children was unlivable, so severely mentally ill that she thought the only way out of her distress was to murder her children and then try to take her own life. It feels uncomfortable to have her name splashed across the front page, the horrific details of her children’s murder getting top billing.
Asking for the ban on naming her and the children to be lifted in its reporting, Deirdre Morley’s trial concluded this week with a not guilty verdict. But in the efforts to explain to complexity and tragedy of the case, some compassion has been lost for the family involved, the horrors of mental illness and the continued absence of sufficient supports for it in this country.
Following the murders, Ms Morley was admitted to Central Mental Hospital and placed on what she called “wonder drug” that’s helped her feel like her old self again. But with this also comes an “unbearable grief”, as she calls it, a desire to go back and change everything. After receiving the help she needed, she could see that her childrens’ attitude were completely normal and not irreparable damage she had inflicted upon them as a “bad mother”.
She was failed by a system that was unable to see the depths of her struggle. Ms Morley had been experienced mental health difficulties since 1996 and been seeking help since 1998. She had been relatively open with mental health professionals, though not her family, about her struggles and had been visiting counsellors and medical professionals. In 2019 she spent time in St Patrick’s Hospital for suicidal ideation. But was only after the murders and the graveness of her crime that she received the help she really needed.
Everything about the Deirdre Morley trial is unspeakably tragic, and my heart goes out to everyone involved. I hope the media will be very mindful on how they report any details of the case. ?
— Maïa Dunphy (@MaiaDunphy) May 19, 2021
In senseless tragedies like this, involving young, innocent children, there is always anger and a need to know how three young lives could be taken. It’s unavoidable and understandable – we’re all mourning the loss of Carla, Conor, and Darragh McGinley as if they were ours. We’re doing the same mourning for their father Andrew, his life will never again be the same.
Their murders are utterly tragic, but we must not forget compassion for Deirdre who will also suffer “unbearable grief” for the rest of her life, knowing what she has done.
She “just wants them back,” she said, during questioning. Her trial has wrapped but various doctors have confirmed she wasn’t of the right mind when she murdered her children – even before the verdict was reached.
Given the nature of what’s happened, there’s something unsettling about the coverage of the case. Did the public really need to know, in-depth, the nature of how her three young children met their end? We know their mother felt she had no choice but to die, but couldn’t bear to leave her children behind. And that such was the nature of her psychotic breakdown, she knew what was happening but simply couldn’t stop it.
But those details are further down in every story – her declining mental health, her intrusive thoughts that she was a bad mother and had ruined her children’s lives as a result, how she tried so hard to mask her symptoms from those closest to her.
There’s something cold about the reporting of this tragedy, a lack of empathy when at the heart of it is a woman who felt so distressed, ill, and alone that death and the killing of her children was the only answer. We can only ache as we know they suffered – and those still here will suffer forever now too.
If you would like to speak to someone or need support, contact Samaritans Ireland on 116 123 or your GP.
CAREERS IN CONVERSATION: Join our seminar series with Sinead Brady, and learn how to build a career you’ll love
The first instalment of Sinead Brady’s career seminar series is available to watch now and is all about how to...
Back in Ireland for palliative chemotherapy, mum of two Vicky Phelan said that she ultimately decided to come home so...
‘The life we are living may not be the one we want’: Meet the career women pivoting because of the pandemic
The Great Resignation is underway, but a financial buffer – as well as bravery – favours those who sail away...
Excluding girls under 17 and women over 25, the new government contraception proposal perpetuates the age-old female stereotypes of chastity...
Vicky Phelan says she is thinking about cancelling a new clinical trial to treat her cancer in the US, which...
Focusing on what Balmain’s creative director looks like after his freak accident is besides the point
Balmain’s creative director, Olivier Rousteing, recently opened up about how a freak household accident left him scarred and ashamed of...
It’s awful, but not surprising that Emily Ratajkowski says she was sexually assaulted on the set of Blurred Lines
In her new book, the model accuses Robin Thicke of groping her on the set of the controversial music video in 2013.