The perfect autumnal hike and overnight stay
The perfect autumnal hike and overnight stay

IMAGE

Small bathroom ideas we’re nabbing from these Irish homes
Small bathroom ideas we’re nabbing from these Irish homes

Megan Burns

‘Ireland is just bursting with talented women’
‘Ireland is just bursting with talented women’

Sarah Finnan

This Stillorgan semi-d was transformed into a luxurious oasis by a travel-loving couple
This Stillorgan semi-d was transformed into a luxurious oasis by a travel-loving couple

Katie Byrne

This adorable Stoneybatter cottage has been reconfigured to create extra space and filled with colour
This adorable Stoneybatter cottage has been reconfigured to create extra space and filled with colour

Megan Burns

Your guide to the IFI’s French Film Festival
Your guide to the IFI’s French Film Festival

Sarah Finnan

Don’t underestimate the power of a perfect outfit
Don’t underestimate the power of a perfect outfit

Edaein OConnell

That’s a wrap: Highlights from the The Pitch 2024
That’s a wrap: Highlights from the The Pitch 2024

IMAGE

My Life in Culture: Artist Conor Harrington
My Life in Culture: Artist Conor Harrington

Sarah Finnan

This Shankill bungalow underwent a thoughtful renovation that expanded the space both up and out
This Shankill bungalow underwent a thoughtful renovation that expanded the space both up and out

Megan Burns

Image / Agenda / Image Writes

Two women posed naked, only one of them drew flak


By Sarah Finnan
13th May 2022
Two women posed naked, only one of them drew flak

Hilary Duff is celebrated while Britney is condemned. The public's attitude to nudity seems to vary depending solely on the celebrity and the circumstance.

The naysayers will tell you “Britney is not ok.” Their argument? A portfolio of naked photos she’s shared with the world on Instagram. But, the public’s aversion to nudity is one reserved solely for Ms Spears.

What dreams are made of?  

As a lifelong Lizzie McGuire fan, Hilary Duff is essentially my god. I saw her in concert, I bought the merch, I pored over her behind-the-scenes tour “book”. Her posters lined my walls and TG4 was my favourite channel growing up, largely because we didn’t have Disney Channel and it’s the only other place I could catch up with Lizzie, Gordo and Miranda on a regular basis. It was an era defined by dial-up connection, lest you forget. 

Three years ago, my heart soared when I learned that a reboot was in the works. Duff would be reprising her role as America’s sweetheart, Covid didn’t exist and all was right in the world. One year later, the reboot was subsequently cancelled and all hopes for an adult take on the series were dashed. 

Duff has stayed in the mainstream since then though, appearing in the recent How I Met Your Father and sharing adorable photos of her three kids on Instagram in the interim. Then, this week, she made headlines for another reason; her Women’s Health magazine cover spread, in which she was completely nude. 

Public response to the photos was mainly positive – albeit, yes, very ageist. “Hilary Duff has aged like a fine wine”, the tweets said of her 34-year-old body. I’m not sure what women in their early to mid-thirties are “supposed” to look like, but it’s not like that, the internet proclaimed. 

https://twitter.com/ImLizzieM/status/1524063489186316289

Flattery flooded in – everyday sexism masquerading as adulation – and popular opinion decided that yes, we approve. 

Oops, she did it again

On the other side of the internet, we have Britney. No stranger to nudity, her Instagram feed is populated by a mixture of aesthetic flat lays, memes, and, well, naked photos of herself. However, unlike the response Duff received, Britney’s posts have instead been met with outrage and faux concern from supposed fans. 

Hilary was praised for her impressive physique after birthing three children. Britney is lambasted for “not having dignity as a mom”. Hilary was branded “classy” and “a body positivity role model”. Britney is written off as “trashy” or “attention seeking”. 

So, what’s the difference? Is it that one set of photos was taken by a professional photographer, while the other was part of a home-orchestrated photoshoot captured on an iPhone? If so, perhaps then, it’s a question of vanity. 

There’s a quote from British essayist John Berger’s book, Ways of Seeing, that speaks to this point. “You painted a naked woman because you enjoyed looking at her, you put a mirror in her hand and you called the painting Vanity, thus morally condemning the woman whose nakedness you had depicted for your own pleasure,” it reads. 

“The real function of the mirror was otherwise. It was to make the women connive in treating herself as, first and foremost, a sight.” 

The female form has long been considered an object of desire, but only when the woman it belongs to is seemingly unaware of her beauty. People feel uncomfortable when women become the architects of their own image… even more so if they dare appreciate how they look themselves. 

Duff has been held up as a beacon of womanhood, while Spears has been infantilised by complete strangers. The internet has appointed itself her new gatekeeper  – they want her to be free, but not *that* free. Too much Britney, reel it in.

https://twitter.com/mattxiv/status/1523766490037899264

What if Britney’s posts aren’t a cry for help as some seem to think, but rather a celebration of freedom in its purest form? The singer was a prisoner to a gruelling conservatorship for 13 long years. Her teenage rebellion was ripped from under her before it could even begin. She couldn’t withdraw money from an ATM, or drive her car or change her contraception without permission… so, it’s probably fair to presume that she couldn’t walk around starkers if she wanted to either. 

As Ru Paul says, we’re all born naked and the rest is drag. Nudity is ok as an infant, it’s ok on the cover of a magazine, and it’s ok if Britney wants to post it on Instagram too.