30 life questions that will strengthen your closest friendships
30 life questions that will strengthen your closest friendships

Geraldine Carton

7 comforting films worth watching to take your mind off Covid
7 comforting films worth watching to take your mind off Covid

Jennifer McShane

This Dalkey home, with sea access and incredible views, is on sale for €3.95 million
This Dalkey home, with sea access and incredible views, is on sale for €3.95 million

Megan Burns

Pandemic regrets: 20 things we would have done differently if we’d known what was ahead
Pandemic regrets: 20 things we would have done differently if we’d known what was ahead

Amanda Cassidy

Marianne Smyth, aka @smythsisters, picks 42 summer staples
Marianne Smyth, aka @smythsisters, picks 42 summer staples

Holly O'Neill

Paris Hilton and the physical, verbal and emotional abuse she suffered while at boarding school
Paris Hilton and the physical, verbal and emotional abuse she suffered while at boarding school

Lauren Heskin

Afore After: The new womenswear brand that’s so sustainable, it uses buttons made from Irish milk
Afore After: The new womenswear brand that’s so sustainable, it uses buttons made from Irish...

Sarah Finnan

6 new Netflix picks we can’t wait to watch in August
6 new Netflix picks we can’t wait to watch in August

Jennifer McShane

Friendship fallout in a pandemic: “I realised that nobody had picked up the phone to see how was I doing”
Friendship fallout in a pandemic: “I realised that nobody had picked up the phone to...

Niamh Ennis

Sophie Toscan du Plantier: 10 questions we’re still asking about the case
Sophie Toscan du Plantier: 10 questions we’re still asking about the case

Jennifer McShane

Image / Fashion

Considering Melania: When A Shoe Is Not Just A Shoe


by Niamh ODonoghue
30th Aug 2017

Credit Doug Mills/The New York Times

First lady Melania Trump has caused another fashion-related outburst this week after setting out for torn-apart Texas wearing not just her trademark stilettos, but an excessively high pair… towering you could stay. The internet erupted with cries bemoaning?Melania’s inappropriate choice of footwear. Wearing a pair of super-high, and no doubt shockingly expensive, shoes to the site of a natural tragedy suggests, not only that she has no plans to get down and dirty helping out the victims, but that she has no understanding of how unrelatable she must look, and how important it is to make yourself relatable when you’re in a position of power. This was Princess Diana’s greatest skill. It begs the question then; when is a shoe not just a shoe? Back in 2015, Fashion Director Marie Kelly argued the importance of flat shoes versus the heel and today its relevance remains front-and-centre.

When French sociologist Marcel Mauss explored how particular styles of shoe influence the wearer’s body, he found that a high heel repositions the body, pulling the hips inwards, tightening the bottom muscles, and pushing the chest forward. A flat shoe, on the?other hand, allows the foot to spread out and the body to relax. Looking stylish has so much to do with knowing the kind of woman you want to be. So, I can look like Barbie (hips inwards, tight bottom, chest pushed forward, etc) always stationary and smiling, or I can look relaxed and at ease, like a woman who has things to do, and who can actually do them without needing the arm of a man to stay upright, or a designated driver.

I reserve the same sort of pity for Barbie, with her feet permanently’moulded to wear pink high heels, as I do for those women who leave the house in heels only to return in flats. After a couple of hours tottering around like Bambi on ice, they peel away their six-inch stilettos only to reveal a mass of blisters, blood and torn stocking, before reaching for the ballet pumps at the bottom of their bags with watery-eyed relief.

?There’s something about having the confidence to wear a shoe that is not ten inches tall that sends a message.?

High heels are often hailed as an empowering accessory, but for me, they’re simply a tool of restriction. I like to walk, more often than not I like to walk fast, and I don’t plan to slow down, not even for fashion. And thankfully, now I don’t have to. American Vogue may be proclaiming that heels are back for 2015, but cushion-soled sliders, mannish brogues with masses of toe room, and chunky loafers with wonderfully wide footbeds walked confidently (and comfortably) down the runway at Marni, Oscar de la Renta, and Derek Lam this season. Statement flats are the practical choice, yes, but they also have a far stronger identity than a generic?outfit, suggest a sexy contradiction between masculine and feminine, and as Stella McCartney put it, ?There’s something about having the confidence to wear a shoe that is not ten inches tall that sends a message.?

It’s no coincidence that around the same time Victoria Beckham swapped her signature sky-scraping stilettoes for a pair of boyish brogues she told The Guardian, ?I used to wear clothes which would make me stand out, and now I don’t have to because I don’t feel I have anything to prove.? The former WAG is now a serious fashion player, and her change of footwear is sartorial proof. And although Beckham hasn’t made the switch permanently (to be fair, she has a designated driver), the over the- top Tributes have been firmly banished in favour of a more discrete mid-height heel or a stylish platform.

It’s true we all need a little help to walk tall sometimes, but for me, it’s a cool shoe like a wedge or a platform, which elevate and elongate without immobilising. Footwear historian William A Rossi maintains that ‘most women prefer a trip to hell in high heels than to walk flat heeled to heaven?. Not me. I’ll follow in the footsteps of C?line’s Phoebe Philo – arguably the most powerful woman in fashion and a firmly rooted flat shoe devotee.

Also Read

FASHION, SHOPPING
Six ways to style your denim this spring

Long-awaited brighter days call for a refresh of our perennial favourite – denim. As we head out into the spring sunshine, our mood this season is ready to play, with sporty silhouettes and a relaxed vibe.

By Holly O'Neill

Alexa Chung Mulberry
FASHION
Alexa Chung has designed a new 1970s-era handbag collection for Mulberry

Now that our social lives are back on track – and we have a reason to leave the house again...

By Sarah Finnan

FASHION, SHOPPING
Light, flowy trousers for in-between summer days

Not quite shorts weather but too warm for jeans? Enter these easy-breezy trouser styles.

By Megan Burns

premium FASHION
Instagram shopping hauls need a sustainability makeover

There’s an Instagram and TikTok trend that sees users unbox large hauls from high street retailers, showing off the glamorous...

By Emily Kielthy

FASHION
GALLERY: 15 iconic wedding dresses we still love now

    With Kate Middleton and Prince William celebrating 10 years of marriage, attention has been focused once again on...

By Jennifer McShane

FASHION, SHOPPING
Ireland’s most stylish women on their summer wishlist buys

The insider intel on what Ireland’s most stylish women are adding to their summer wardrobes.

By Holly O'Neill

FASHION
Jimmy Choo launches a collection designed by fan sketches

It started as a lockdown Instagram competition and resulted in a one-of-a-kind Jimmy Choo shoe collection. Jimmy Choo has released...

By Louise Slyth