How to pull off the Absolute Right Outfit for a wedding
How to pull off the Absolute Right Outfit for a wedding

IMAGE

The best black boots to strut your stuff in this autumn
The best black boots to strut your stuff in this autumn

Sarah Finnan

This spatchcock chicken recipe will make your weekend
This spatchcock chicken recipe will make your weekend

Meg Walker

Catch yourself on, ‘Derry Girls’ is not ‘distinctively British’
Catch yourself on, ‘Derry Girls’ is not ‘distinctively British’

Sarah Finnan

8 easy ways to keep your brain healthy that you can do right now
8 easy ways to keep your brain healthy that you can do right now

IMAGE

Over half of us are cleansing wrong – here’s how it’s done
Over half of us are cleansing wrong – here’s how it’s done

Holly O'Neill

‘Trying to dress my bump for four weddings and a funeral’
‘Trying to dress my bump for four weddings and a funeral’

Kate White

The dark world of mommy vlogging takes another blow
The dark world of mommy vlogging takes another blow

Holly O'Neill

This Georgian Leopardstown home full of country charm is on sale for €2.7 million
This Georgian Leopardstown home full of country charm is on sale for €2.7 million

Megan Burns

The treatment of the women’s rugby Interpros is sadly indicative of all women’s sports in Ireland
The treatment of the women’s rugby Interpros is sadly indicative of all women’s sports in...

Lauren Heskin

Image / Editorial

5 Books Infinitely Better Than The Movie


by Jennifer McShane
19th May 2016
blank

How often do we wait in anticipation for our favourite novels to get a big-screen adaptation only to be sorry we ever viewed them? Yes, some movies can be better than their source material?(Fight Club being this writer’s favourite example), but they usually come up short, opting for stylised visuals and plot twists solely intent on driving the film forward rather than showcasing a character’s depth or sense of self. ?Much more could be added to this list, but below are five books of choice that Hollywood should have left well alone.

Lolita by Vladamir Nabokov

book-covers-bshk-20

Lolita?is one of those books where its greatness is almost entirely dependent on the particular literary gifts of its author and the beguiling voice of its unreliable narrator. This is why it remains a literary masterpiece; yes, the subject matter is uncomfortable but such is the quality of the writing it refrains from being overly creepy or distasteful. In terms of film, a few respectable adaptations have been made, and Kubrick’s loose take on the novel is widely considered a’solid effort, but every big-screen effort lacks the dark humour and essential?backstory so present in the book and?Humbert, who the reader can’t help but see as a tragic figure, never comes across as such on film.

Emma by Jane Austen

penguin-threads-emma-book-cover

This 1996 adaptation, which helped launch Gwyneth Paltrow to superstardom, is, at best, polite and visually very pleasing but essentially unforgettable. The energy, wit, and enormous heart of Austen’s voice are what make this book a classic, and sadly, the film is devoid of all this. It has been updated?eight times, six times for television and two for a feature film, but it’s widely agreed that no adaptation has done the original novel justice.

The Time Traveler’s Wife by?Audrey Niffenegger

51zzmo

Henry DeTamble is a time traveller, although not by choice. A genetic mutation causes him to spontaneously travel through time, disappearing from view, leaving behind his clothes and possessions, and arriving naked in another time and another place. This is the basis of Niffenegger’s remarkable debut novel. It’s?a love story as opposed to science fiction and beautifully written; the time travel is seamless and believable?throughout, so much so that it never once seems far-fetched. The big qualm with the film adaptation was that the connection between the Clare and Henry that is paramount in the book is absent in the film; the emotional undercurrents just aren’t there and therefore, the viewer doesn’t invest in them.

The Lovely Bones by?Alice Sebold

book_cover__the_lovely_bones_by_neurotripsy

This was Sebold’s first novel, and it remains her most successful. The Lovely Bones, with its posthumous narrator telling the story of her brutal rape and murder and the subsequent?aftermath?of both?tragic events, isn’t exactly a light read,?it is completely compelling. The reader is given infinite time and detail in which to bond with each character?- all of whom play a central part in the story – and that is what the film lacks; time. Everything feels rushed in an attempt to get the main details to the big screen and in doing so,?the reader doesn’t engage or empathise with the characters.?It’s a wasted adaptation of a wonderful novel.

Flowers in the Attic by?V.C. Andrews

Screen shot 2016-05-19 at 16.25.38

It’s currently a TV series, but it was made in 1992 featuring many unknown actors. Stay well away from both offerings as neither conveys the truly haunting story of children who live their twilight years in an attic. ?V.C Andrews is a master storyteller; she makes an unrealistic storyline feel utterly real and incredibly terrifying – this is no attic, but a prison in which they may never escape. The film is less compelling, the characters (particularly?the mother) are too bland to be convincing. ?The entire Flowers trilogy makes for sublime reading, so add it to your reading lists.

Which of your favourite books have we left out?

Also Read

blank
AGENDA, EDITORIAL
When speaking about ageing, we should follow Julianne Moore’s lead

Actress Julianne Moore is tired of all the cliched tropes about female ageing. The way we speak about it; the...

By Jennifer McShane

blank
AGENDA, EDITORIAL
No, the Olympics haven’t given athletes ‘anti-sex’ cardboard beds

Despite some media coverage, the beds are actually focused on sustainability as opposed to intimacy restrictions. Recently, distance runner Paul...

By Jennifer McShane

blank
CULTURE
Reality Bites: TV shows like Love Island are warping our minds

It may be the most unifying show on television, but shows like Love Island are promoting some pretty damaging messages....

By Amanda Cassidy

blank
EDITORIAL
This spatchcock chicken recipe will make your weekend

This is a great way to get a juicy roast chicken, bursting with flavour.     Bord Bia’s Spatchcock Chicken...

By Meg Walker

alternative asthma treatments
EDITORIAL
Three alternative asthma treatments to try this hayfever season

Approximately 80% of people with asthma also suffer from hayfever, which can make summer days a nightmare. These three alternative...

By Grace McGettigan

blank
EDITORIAL
Sarah Harding’s heartbroken mum announces the singer’s death aged just 39

Sarah Harding has died at the age of just 39, her heartbroken mother revealed today. The Girls Aloud star had...

By Amanda Cassidy

blank
EDITORIAL
‘Quite interesting’: Princess Anne comments on The Crown

We’ve all heard that the royal family don’t exactly gather round to watch The Crown, but one member has shared...

By Jennifer McShane